Identification of Limits to Development of Innovative Affordable Housing Types in the Tucson Area

April 18, 2022

Social Equity + Zoning

Overview
Architecture lecturer Bill Mackey investigates the development regulations, costs and trends within the metropolitan Tucson region associated with “innovative” housing types on individual lots for a Drachman Institute project funded by AARP.
Who
Bill Mackey, Lecturer in Architecture
Where
Pima County, City of Tucson, Town of Oro Valley and the City of South Tucson
When
October 2020 - January 2021
Categories
Aerial map of illegal guest houses

Project Overview

Investigation of the development regulations, costs and trends within the metropolitan Tucson region associated with “innovative” housing types on individual lots. The housing types in question were accessory dwelling units (ADU), missing middle housing (duplex/triplex/fourplex), tiny homes, and manufactured housing. The area of the study included Pima County, City of Tucson, Town of Oro Valley and the City of South Tucson. For each jurisdiction, the team interviewed zoning and planning staff regarding zoning codes and permitting processes, reviewed zoning code for specific regulations, spoke with general contractors and banking professionals regarding costs, and interviewed developers and architects currently involved in current projects applicable to the study.

Project Outcomes and Recommendations

White Paper and Presentation for Affordable Housing Summit Tucson 2021.

  1. Jurisdiction should RECOGNIZE accessory dwelling units as a viable housing option for the citizens of metropolitan Tucson. ADUs should be defined in the various land use codes and development regulations should be assigned to ADUs.
  2. INCREASE the percentage of land area in the metropolitan Tucson region for the development of ADUs and MMH. As it currently stands, ADUs can only be built on a fraction of the properties in the metro area. Yet, we are aware that many, many properties currently have fully functioning ADUs.
  3. UPDATE standards for parking and vehicle access for residential properties. Special processes exist for the reduction of parking requirements within many of the codes, but we suggest you make the reductions part of the standard code language or at least provide specific standards for ADUs. Also consider revising the Residential Parking Permit program as the city population and density increases.
  4. UPDATE standards for building setbacks, building height and lot coverage that balance current standards and existing context/fabric. Many building setback requirements indicated in the existing codes could not be met by the existing fabric of Tucson.
  5. RECONSIDER the current code definitions of family, dwelling unit, kitchen and group dwelling. Redefining these terms may allow an increase in innovative housing types.
  6. RECONSIDER the process required for the permitting of residential rental properties. Is a professional sealant required for the construction documents? Is a general contractor required for the construction? Can the code and process be made simple enough for an average citizen to develop their property? Can planning staff offer more guidance for the development of properties?

Community Partners

  • American Association of Retired Persons (AARP)

Gallery

Identification of Limits to Development of Innovative Affordable Housing Types in the Tucson Area, by Bill Mackey
Identification of Limits to Development of Innovative Affordable Housing Types in the Tucson Area, by Bill Mackey
Identification of Limits to Development of Innovative Affordable Housing Types in the Tucson Area, by Bill Mackey
Identification of Limits to Development of Innovative Affordable Housing Types in the Tucson Area, by Bill Mackey
Identification of Limits to Development of Innovative Affordable Housing Types in the Tucson Area, by Bill Mackey
Identification of Limits to Development of Innovative Affordable Housing Types in the Tucson Area, by Bill Mackey
Identification of Limits to Development of Innovative Affordable Housing Types in the Tucson Area, by Bill Mackey
Identification of Limits to Development of Innovative Affordable Housing Types in the Tucson Area, by Bill Mackey

Latest CAPLA News, Projects and Profiles

Lauren Bon

Lecture Recap | The Cyborg Watershed of the American West | A Jones Studio Grand Challenges Lecture featuring Lauren Bon

An engineered network of waterways flowing west from the Rockies sustains life in one of the hottest regions on Earth, forming a “cyborg watershed” that blends natural systems with human-made infrastructure and regional mythologies. Bon explored this system through her large-scale artworks, examining buried waterways, the complexities of policy and politics, and the pursuit of a civic identity shaped by water rather than boundaries.

Group photo of four CAPLA students who are members of the ISAPD

CAPLA to host Indigenous Design Symposium focused on community, sustainability

CAPLA’s Indigenous Society of Architecture, Planning and Design (ISAPD) will host an all-day symposium on April 6, bringing together students, faculty and practitioners to explore Indigenous approaches to the built environment. Featuring Indigenous designers and supported by campus partners, the event will highlight community-centered design, sustainability and the role of Indigenous knowledge systems in shaping more responsible relationships with land.

See More